Because the following story concerns private property and possible health risks to would-be explorers I’ve taken care to conceal the location of the cave and the identities of those involved.
A number of years ago a man presented himself at a Maplewood citizen’s (who I’ll call BH) front door and said he was a spelunker. He told BH that he knew there was a cave in the vicinity and would BH mind if he had a look in his backyard. BH didn’t mind and showed the caver where two manhole covers were located very close to one another. The first is a cover for a storm sewer. The second turned out to have a different purpose. It is an access to what I’m suggesting we call Sutton’s Cave.
The spelunker wasted no time in removing the cover and scurrying down the manhole. BH said the man was well equipped and an experienced member of a local spelunking society. In spite of that after the spelunker had been gone several hours, he began to worry. It was nearing sunset when the mud-covered man finally reemerged and told BH that there was a very large cave that went on and on.
While doing research for the Maplewood history book I realized that this location (BH’s backyard) is very close to the site where James Sutton (Maplewood's first settler) constructed a home in 1826. To reveal the source of this information would be to reveal the location.
According to this source “The first house…was put up at a point…near a spring that is yet situated … down at the rear of Mrs. Poertner’s lot.” My investigation determined the likely location of the spring. The present day entrance to the cave is extremely close to the former location of the spring. Indeed it appears that the spring may have at some time in the past been routed to empty into the cave itself.
In 2010, acting out of curiosity, I contacted a local group of responsible spelunkers. They came out and verified that the manhole in question was an access point to the cave. They informed me that it would be very unhealthy to try and explore this cave without the proper equipment. These days urban caves often have sewage in them. The air can be deadly.
The cavers, extremely nice and knowledgeable fellows all, recorded the location and at my suggestion listed it as Sutton’s Cave. They knew of another very large cave fairly close by that had also been capped with a manhole cover. The manhole cover which now caps the Sutton cave is not typical. It is much thicker and heavier than normal. It was obviously meant to allow access but not easy access to the cave in the future.
Sutton most likely made use of the spring. He and others must have made use of the cave as well. I wonder if they left anything down there.